The client was prosecuted for failing to provide breath. The breath test device was faulty and the police failed to arrange a social worker which was a legal requirement as the client was vulnerable. Philip Lucas instructed by Sandra Cooper (reviewing lawyer) persuaded the court to dismiss the case as the prosecution had failed to respond to the defence case statement until the date of trial and various items of evidence were not disclosed including CCTV from intox procedure, body cam footage and printout from the abortive breath test procedure.